Independent claim appraisal in all 58 California countiesinfo@californiainsuranceappraiser.com+1 (844) 537-1427
CaliforniaInsurance Appraiser (844) 537-1427

Appraisal service

Neutral Insurance Appraisal Umpire Services

When two appraisers can’t agree, the umpire decides the items in dispute. We serve as a neutral umpire on panels where we represent neither the policyholder nor the carrier.

Role
Neutral third panelist
Seated by
Appraisers or a judge
Decides
Only the differences

The umpire’s job

Under California’s standard appraisal wording, the two appraisers first try to agree on the amount of loss. Only the items they cannot agree on go to the umpire. An insurance appraisal umpire reviews both appraisers’ positions on those items, inspects as needed, and signs an award with whichever appraiser agrees, or proposes figures both can accept.

How umpires are chosen

The appraisers are supposed to agree on a competent and disinterested umpire. If they can’t within 15 days, either side can ask a judge to appoint one. Courts generally prefer candidates with construction, estimating or prior panel experience and no conflicts with either party.

Our umpire standards

  • Disclosure first: before accepting, we disclose any prior relationship with the carrier, either appraiser, the policyholder or counsel.
  • Clear ground rules: a written outline of submissions, inspection, timing and fees agreed by both appraisers.
  • Itemized awards: actual cash value and replacement cost stated separately for each disputed item, as the standard form contemplates.
  • No coverage rulings: we value the loss and leave coverage and causation questions to the parties and, if needed, the courts.

Fees

Under the standard wording, umpire fees are shared equally by the policyholder and the insurer. We set an hourly or flat fee in writing at the outset, with an estimate of hours based on the number and complexity of disputed items.

Availability

We accept umpire appointments statewide, in every California county. When we have represented a party on an unrelated claim with the same carrier or appraiser, we disclose it and let both appraisers decide.

Questions about umpire services

Can the umpire hear from me directly?

Usually the appraisers present each side’s position. The umpire may allow the parties to attend inspections or submit documents, depending on the ground rules.

Can the umpire decide coverage?

No. The umpire, like the appraisers, values the loss. Coverage disputes belong to the parties and the courts.

How long does umpire review take?

Often a few weeks after submissions, depending on the number of disputed items and whether an inspection is needed.

Related services

Is the carrier’s number short?

Send the estimate and your photos. We’ll review them and tell you plainly what we see.