Independent claim appraisal in all 58 California countiesinfo@californiainsuranceappraiser.com+1 (844) 537-1427
CaliforniaInsurance Appraiser (844) 537-1427

Free estimator

Appraisal Payoff Estimator: Will Appraisal Be Worth the Cost?

Enter the carrier’s estimate and yours, choose where an award might land, and add realistic fees. The estimator shows whether appraisal is likely to leave you ahead.

Appraisal payoff estimator

Runs in your browser
Replacement cost total on the insurer’s estimate.
Your contractor’s or independent estimate.
55%
0% means the carrier’s number holds. 100% means your full number is awarded.
Estimated net increase to you$0
Carrier’s numberYour net gainAppraisal costs
Amount in dispute$0
Gap as % of carrier estimate—
Projected award (RCV)$0
Gross increase$0
Your appraisal costs$0

For planning only. Results depend on what you enter and on your policy, and aren’t a quote, an appraisal or legal advice. Nothing you type leaves your browser.

How to use the payoff estimator

  1. Enter the carrier’s RCV total, the replacement cost figure before depreciation and deductible.
  2. Enter your estimate, also at replacement cost.
  3. Move the slider to test outcomes. Try 30%, 50% and 80% to see a range.
  4. Add fees. Use your appraiser’s quoted arrangement and a realistic umpire fee.

Reading the result

Awards rarely match either opening number. Documented line items tend to hold and unsupported ones tend to fall. If your result only works at 90% or more, the case is fragile. If it still makes sense at 40%, appraisal is more likely to be worthwhile. All default figures are illustrative.

What it leaves out

It doesn’t model depreciation timing, policy limits or deductibles. For holdback math, use the ACV and holdback calculator; for total losses, try the rebuild cost check.

Questions about this tool

Is the projected award a prediction?

No. It’s a planning scenario. Real awards depend on documentation, the panel and the policy.

How much is a typical umpire fee?

It varies with the size and complexity of the dispute. Under the standard California wording, the umpire’s fee is split equally.

More free tools

Want a professional to check the numbers?

Send us your estimate and we’ll review it line by line.