California roofs aren’t one roof
Clay and concrete tile dominates much of Southern California and the inland valleys. Composition shingle is common in Northern California suburbs. Older foothill homes may still have wood shake, which many jurisdictions now restrict in fire hazard areas. Low-slope roofs cover Eichlers, mid-century homes and most commercial buildings. A roof damage appraisal starts by identifying exactly what is on the house.
Where roof estimates come up short
- Underlayment under tile: tile is a water-shedding layer; the underlayment does the waterproofing. If it has aged out, repairing broken tile without replacing it may not be a real repair.
- Discontinued profiles: many tile and shingle lines have been discontinued. If replacements can’t reasonably match, the dispute becomes how much of the roof must be replaced.
- Pitch and access: steep roofs and hillside homes need extra labor, safety equipment and sometimes cranes.
- Accessories: drip edge, flashing, vents, ridge and hip pieces, bird stops and gutters are frequently left off.
- Code: reroofing in very high fire hazard severity zones may require Class A roof assemblies and ember-resistant vents.
Wind, hail and heat
Santa Ana and Diablo winds lift and break tile and peel shingles along ridges and rakes. Hail is less common than in the middle of the country but does fall in the Central Valley, the Sierra foothills and high desert, and occasionally in coastal storms. Heat accelerates shingle aging, which carriers sometimes cite to argue wear and tear. We document fresh damage carefully so the panel can separate it from age.
How we measure
We take field measurements and compare them against aerial reports, then check every slope, pitch and penetration. Use our roof area and pitch calculator to sanity-check the square count on your estimate before you call.
What the panel will want to see
Dated photos, close-ups of broken or lifted materials, attic photos showing water entry, the manufacturer and profile of your tile or shingle, and any repair invoices. If you have a contractor’s roof report, send it along.
Questions about roof damage appraisal
The adjuster said my tile roof only needs a few replacement tiles. Is that right?
Sometimes. If the underlayment is sound and matching tile is available, a spot repair can be reasonable. If not, a larger replacement may be justified.
Will my policy pay for a fire-rated roof upgrade?
If your policy includes building code upgrade coverage and the code requires it for the repair, part or all of it may be owed. Check the limit on your declarations page.
How do you tell storm damage from wear?
Fresh fractures, displaced pieces, creasing and directional patterns point to a storm event. We document them with dated photos and measurements.
