Independent claim appraisal in all 58 California countiesinfo@californiainsuranceappraiser.com+1 (844) 537-1427
CaliforniaInsurance Appraiser (844) 537-1427

Guide · 6 min read · August 25, 2026

How to Read a Carrier’s Estimate Before You Accept It

Carrier estimates look precise. A line-by-line read often shows missing items, low quantities and depreciation that doesn’t add up.

Most carrier estimates are written in Xactimate or similar software. They look authoritative, but they reflect choices about scope and pricing. Here is how to read one.

Start with the summary

Find the replacement cost total, depreciation, deductible and net claim. Check that prior payments are credited correctly.

Check the scope room by room

Every damaged room, slope and elevation should appear. Missing areas are the most common source of gaps.

Check quantities

Compare square footage, linear feet and roof squares against your own measurements. Our roof area calculator can help with the roof.

Check repair versus replace

Look at whether items are repaired, cleaned or replaced. Matching, discontinued materials and code requirements can justify replacement.

Check unit prices

Price lists are regional, but they may not reflect current local costs, especially after a disaster. Compare with your contractor’s pricing.

Check depreciation

Depreciation should reflect age and condition. Look for flat percentages applied to everything.

Check overhead and profit

When several trades are needed, general contractor overhead and profit is often appropriate.

Then decide

Many gaps close with a documented supplement. If not, a professional insurance estimate review can tell you whether appraisal is worth pursuing.

Keep reading

Is the carrier’s number short?

Send the estimate and your photos. We’ll review them and tell you plainly what we see.